| |

The Watergate Hotel, site of the burglary that would lead
to the resignation of Richard Nixon
|
|
He seemed a contented
man. House Minority Leader Gerald R. Ford, had his niche. He had
served twelve terms as a congressman, never receiving less than
60 percent of the vote from his constituents back in Grand Rapids,
Michigan. Ford did not hunger to be president of the United States.
As he once said, "When I first ran for the Congress I had an
ambition to be a good legislator, and when I got to Washington as
a member of the House . . . to be a very good legislator."1
One last ambition, a chance to be Speaker of the House toward the
end of his career, was thwarted when the Republicans didnt
win a majority in the House. Nevertheless, he believed he had served
his home district well, and, as he told his wife Betty, he would
retire from a very satisfying public career by January 1977. Yet
a chain of political events was about to take his life in a direction
he could never have imagined.
Unbeknownst to Ford, the first link in the chain was the infamous
Watergate break-in. Early on the morning of June 17, 1972, five
Cubans were caught in a burglary at the Democratic National Committee
headquarters at the Watergate office complex in Washington; two
others had been arrested not long afterwards and charged with supervising
the break-in. At first it seemed "penny-ante," but when
two reporters from the Washington Post began to investigate
they discovered that among those involved in the burglary were former
employees of the Committee to Re-Elect the President (soon popularly
called CREEP). At least one of them worked in the White House itself.
In addition, they had been paid for the break-in from a secret fund
of the reelection committee, controlled by staff members at the
White House. Public interest in the disclosures was not great in
the beginning, and few questioned President Richard M. Nixon when
he said that neither he nor his staff had anything to do with "this
very bizarre incident." 2 Nixon sailed through his bid for
re-election. His opponent, Democrat George McGovern, won the electoral
votes of only Massachusetts and the District of Columbia.
The
White House Connection
Early in 1973, however, the Watergate burglars went on trial, and
under unyielding prodding from federal judge John Sirica, one of
the defendants, James W. McCord, agreed to cooperate with both the
grand jury and a special Senate investigating committee.3 McCords
testimony resulted in a torrent of admissions, and for months a
procession of White House and campaign officials exposed questionable
or illegal actions. One of those was a member of the presidents
inner circle, White House counsel John Dean. Dean leveled charges
against President Nixon himself. It seemed clear that there had
been abuses of power involving both the White House staff and the
Nixon campaign committee. There were the White House "plumbers,"
under the direction of John Ehrlichman, whose mission had been to
investigate and harass political opponents through illegal wiretaps,
intercepted mail, and burglaries.4 Illegal campaign contributions
had been "laundered" in Mexico and used to support a variety
of "dirty tricks" against Democratic presidential candidates
and to pay for other activities aimed at sabotaging the campaigns
of Nixons opponents. Then there was the Watergate break-in
itself. Part of a million dollar security and intelligence-gathering
plan called Operation Gemstone, some claimed it had been
initiated by Dean, while others placed the blame on Attorney General
John Mitchell.5 Though it seemed clear that Nixon neither planned
nor approved the burglary in advance, there was more and more evidence
that he had been involved to some degree in a cover-up, although
after the fact.
"No
Contest"
Meanwhile, Nixons vice president, Spiro Agnew, had his own
problems. He was accused of having accepted bribes and kickbacks
while governor of Maryland. In exchange for an agreement on the
part of the Justice Department not to further prosecute the case,
he plea-bargained, admitting "nolo contendere" (no contest)
to a lesser charge. Shortly thereafter, he resigned. 6 Gerald Ford
explained how he heard about the decision that would change his
life. About two days before the Agnew story broke, Nixon invited
him to come down to the Executive Office Building for a talk. He
had known Nixon since January 1949, when Nixon, then a congressman,
had welcomed him as a "freshman" representative from Grand
Rapids to the House. Now, during a ninety-minute conversation, they
reminisced about their long friendship, mutual friends, and goals
theyd shared within their party over the years. Ford got a
phone call telling him to get back to the House floor for a roll-call
vote. As he arrived, two of his House colleagues grabbed him by
the arm and said, "Agnews resigning!" Then Ford
understood the timeliness of his visit to the president. Nixon was
considering him as the next vice president.7
With an overflow crowd
of cabinet members, the leaders and committee powers of Congress,
White House staff, and prime-time television networks, Nixon nominated
Gerald R. Ford as vice president of the United States at the White
House on October 12, 1973. Ford was the first person to be nominated
under the Twenty-Fifth Amendment, ratified in 1967, which, among
other things, provided for filling vacancies in the vice presidency.
After a reception at the White House, the Fords left for their
home across the Potomac River in Alexandria, Virginiaunder
guard by the Secret Service for the first time.
The
Saturday Night Massacre
Meanwhile,
the White House scandal became even more heated. Alexander Butterfield,
a White House staffer, offered Senate Watergate Committee investigators
an important piece of information. There was a tape-recording
device in all four offices the president used, including the White
House Oval Office. Almost every conversation between the president
and his staff that had taken place during the time after the Watergate
break-in had been recorded! 8 All those investigating the scandals
wanted to listen to the tapes, but Nixon refused, saying that
action would compromise his right to the confidentiality of conversations
in his office, a claim known as "executive privilege."
When the Justice Departments special prosecutor, Archibald
Cox, went to court to force the evidence, Nixon ordered his attorney
general, Elliot Richardson, to fire Cox. Richardson refused to
do so, and resigned in protest; the deputy attorney general refused
as well, and was dismissed before he could resign. Finally, another
official in the Justice Department, Robert Bork, agreed to carry
out the firing. The so-called Saturday Night Massacre released
a fire storm of protest, with nearly a half million telegrams
bombarding the White House in one week. Furthermore, when Speaker
Carl Albert called the House of Representatives to order on the
Tuesday morning after the firings, a score of them were waiting
in line to introduce resolutions of impeachment of the president
of the United States. Under the hail of public protest, Nixon
yielded nine tapes.9
Setting
New Precedents
As
the House and Senate prepared the confirmation hearings that
would make Gerald Ford vice president, they understood that they
had an awesome responsibility in front of them. According to
the Twenty-Fifth Amendment, the appointment had to be confirmed
by a majority of both Houses. Members of confirmation committees
on both sides of the Congress knew they were establishing precedents.
For the first time in the history of the republic, a vice president
of the United States would be confirmed by the 535 members of
the U.S. Congress, not the vote of the Electoral College, whose
decisions reflected the popular election. In a sense, Congress
had been asked to act as the Electoral College. In letting his
committee know the import of the task, the chairman of the Senate
Committee on Rules and Administration, Howard Cannon said, "It
is for the members of this committee to establish a precedenta
solid, Constitutional precedentby pursuing an orderly,
logical, thorough, and honest inquiry into the nominees
qualifications."10
In the politically
charged environment of Watergate and the Agnew scandal, Gerald
Ford, too, wanted Congress to have no doubts about his qualifications.
He told his advisors, "Hold nothing back," and, according
to historian James Cannon, "directed his lawyer, his accountant,
his banker, his doctor, his peers in the House, his personal friends,
and his brothers to put everything on the record."11 At the
end of the investigation, the FBI had interviewed more than a
thousand people, producing a report of 1,700 single-spaced pages.
In accepting their responsibility for choosing someone for the
vice presidency, the congressional committee members collected
more information about a public official than had ever been known
about any person in or out of American public office.12 Ford was
confirmed. Even then, many on Capitol Hill understood that they
had chosen not only the vice president, but perhaps the future
president as well. On December 6, 1973, Ford took the oath of
office in the House chamber, using a Bible given to him by his
oldest son, while his wife looked on.
An
Accelerating Crisis
By early
1974, the Watergate crisis had come to a full boil. In April,
a federal grand jury indicted Nixons former attorney general,
John Mitchell, along with the presidents top aides, John
Ehrlichman, and H. R. Haldeman, plus others in high positions
in the Nixon administration. Nixon himself was named as a "co-conspirator."
Then both the House Judiciary Committee and the new federal prosecutor,
Leon Jaworski, subpoenaed more tapes. In an effort to head off
still more subpoenas, the president released a 1,308-page transcript
of certain edited tapes, saying these tapes proved his innocence.
The reaction seemed worse than had come after the Saturday Night
Massacre. Even with many expletives deleted, the public was stunned
at the "insider" view the tapes revealed. The writers
of The National Experience declared that the tapes displayed
Nixon as a profane man, seemingly "mean-spirited, and amoral."13
The furor over the release of the tapes nearly eclipsed an announcement
by the presidents senior defense lawyer, James D. St. Clair,
that Nixon would not hand over the tapes and documents
that Judge Sirica had subpoenaed.14 The president appealed this
subpoena, eventually to the Supreme Court, saying it was within
his power as president to withhold the tapes. The demand for Nixons
impeachment rose to a new level.
A
Smoking Gun
In July
the Supreme Court ruled unanimously, in the United States v.
Richard M. Nixon, that the president had to relinquish all
of the White House tapessixty-four in allto the special
prosecutor. Nixons attorneys advised him that if he didnt
give over the tapes, any support he had in Congress would be gone;
impeachment would be assured. Nixon knew that impeachment most
likely was assured anyway. For unlike his attorneys, the president
knew exactly what the tapes would reveal, especially one from
a June 23, 1972, meeting, only six days after the Watergate break-in.
He knew that when the prosecutor heard that tape, the one in which
he agreed to use the Central Intelligence Agency to stop the Federal
Bureau of Investigation probe of the Watergate break-in, he would
be clearly implicated in the cover up. Nixon asked his legal counsel
to listen to that tape, and assess its legal implications. When
Nixons attorney, Fred Buzhardt, heard the tape, he called
Alexander Haig, the presidents chief of staff, and said,
"Well, weve found the smoking pistol!"15 Still
another of the presidents defense attorneys, James St. Clair,
read a transcript of the tape. When Haig called St. Clair and
asked him how damaging it was to Nixon, he answered in one word,
"Fatal."16
A few days after the
Supreme Court decision, after weeks of hearings, the House Judiciary
Committee voted three articles of impeachment, charging Nixon
with obstruction of justice in the Watergate case, with violating
the rights of certain citizens with regard to the administration
of justice, and with unconstitutionally denying the Committees
subpoenas.
Get
Ready for A Change
Since
Gerald Ford had become vice president, he had walked a very uncomfortable
line. In private he disagreed with some of the actions that he
knew had been taken by the Nixon White House. Ford believed that
Nixon had always been truthful with him, and Nixon had denied
any wrongdoing in this matter. For a while Ford simply thought
the president was getting some very bad advice. Though as time
went by, he had more and more suspicions that Nixon was involved
in the Watergate cover up, he still held onto the idea that legal
and congressional processes would make the judgment. Furthermore,
as he said, "It was a very narrow path for nine months. If
I was critical of Nixon, the press and the public would have said,
well, he was trying to undercut Nixon so he will get the job.
On the other hand, if I stayed too loyal it might appear that
I was supporting somebody who was involved in this very unwise
action. . . . It was not a pleasant experience."17
"Be ready for
a change in your life." That was Alexander Haigs advice
to Gerald Ford on August 1, when he talked with him the first
time about the "smoking gun." He outlined what White
House lawyers saw as the presidents options in the wake
of the damaging tapes, mentioning, for example, that Nixon could
actually pardon himself and resign. Then, as Ford remembered it,
"Finally, Haig said that according to some on Nixons
White House staff, Nixon could agree to leave in return for an
agreement that the new presidentGerald Fordwould pardon
him." Ford listened to all of the suggested options, including
that one, but as he said, "I did not urge Haig to do anything
to get Nixon to resign. That was his choice."18 Perhaps
it was, but Fords close personal advisor, Bryce Harlow,
told the vice president that if he became president, "There
must not be any cause for anyone to cry deal if you
have to make that decision [a pardon], or any mystery about your
position now that you know what Haig . . . [has] told you."19
Harlows reasoning weighed on Ford. Thinking back on his
conversations with Haig, and the implications suggested by other
advisors as well as Harlow, Ford decided he needed to clarify
with Nixons chief of staff exactly what his position was.
The next day, he called Haig at the White House. To be sure his
message would be clear, he had written it out, and read it to
the chief of staff over the phone: "I want you to understand
that I have no intention of recommending what the president should
do about resigning or not resigning, and that nothing we talked
about yesterday afternoon should be given any consideration in
whatever decision the president may wish to make." Haigs
reply: "Youre absolutely right."20
At 4:00 p.m. on August
5, 1974, the White House released the transcript of the June 23
tape, along with a 1,000-word statement by Nixon attempting
to justify his actions in the Watergate cover-up. Despite the
explanation, Nixon understood that once the transcript became
public, he could not escape the anger throughout the land. Moreover,
an important Republican leader, Senator Barry Goldwater, had given
him the count. In the Senate, Nixon had just six senators who
would vote against an impeachment conviction. As Goldwater said,
"Its finished." On the morning of August 6, Nixon
met with his cabinet, and in an atmosphere that seemed surreal,
tried to conduct business as usual. George Bush, in attendance
as the chairman of the Republican National Committee, could not
bear to hear a mundane discussion of inflation problems continue,
as if it were a normal meeting. Raising his hand, he stated bluntly,
"Mr. President, you have to resign."21 It hit
like a ton of bricks.
Transitions
By mid-afternoon, Tuesday, August 6, 1974, President Nixon had
made the decision that he would resign. At 3:30 p.m. he picked
up a yellow legal pad and wrote "Resignation Speech"
on top, then made several pages of notes to give his speechwriter,
who would draft his final speech.22 That Thursday, August 8, Ford
was summoned to the White House to see the president. When Ford
was seated, he recalled that Nixon came right to the point, "I
have made a decision to resign. Its in the best interest
of the country. I wont go into the pros and cons of it,
Ive made my decision." Ford related that he told the
president he was ready to do the job, and Nixon agreed. After
that, according to Ford, the president relaxed, and talked about
the problems Ford would face in economic and foreign affairs,
mentioning nothing about Watergate or the possibility of a pardon.
Nixon made practical suggestions, including reminding Ford that
he would be nominating a vice president. "Its your
choice," he had told him, but mentioned Nelson Rockefeller
as "a good man."23

President Nixon's letter of resignation |
|

The Nixons depart the White House |
|

Gerald R. Ford is sworn in as president |
|

Gerald R. Ford pardons Richard Nixon |
Then Nixon switched
the conversation to the protocol of transitions, even this one.
He had a plan well in mind. He and his family would go to the
East Room to say good-bye to the staff and the cabinet. After
that, they would walk directly through the diplomatic entrance
of the White House to the helicopter. From Andrews Air Force Base
they would fly in Air Force One for San Clemente, their
home. Nixon suggested that the Fords walk with them to the helicopter.
The president wanted to know where Ford planned to be sworn in.
Ford said he had decided not to go to Capitol Hillit might
seem too much like a celebration. Nixon told him he could be sworn
in at the White House. "Ill be gone before noon,"
he said.24
At 12:03 p.m. on August 9, 1974, in the East Room of the White
House, Gerald R. Ford took the oath of office as president. His
remarks reflected his understanding of how he came to be president:
"I am acutely aware that you have not elected me as your
President by your ballots, and so I ask you to confirm me as your
President with your prayers." Another memorable line from
the speech expressed his hope for the country: "My fellow
Americans, our long national nightmare is over."25 President
Fords task was straightforward: he had to relieve the anger
and anxiety in the country and to give Americans a sense that
a decent, respectable person was in the White House. For almost
a month he did just that. There was an almost palpable sigh of
relief, with Fords approval rating reaching 70 percent.
Complying with the Twenty-Fifth Amendment, Ford nominated New
York governor, Nelson Rockefeller, for vice president. For the
first time in history both the president and vice president had
come to office and power not like all other predecessors, through
election, but through appointment and confirmation. Most people
seemed able to accept that unusual circumstance of the Ford administration.
Yet when he made the decision to pardon Nixon, it would be a different
matter.
Fall-Out
Thirty
days after President Ford took office, on Sunday, September 8,
he gave Richard Nixon and "full, free, and absolute pardon
for all Watergate crimes." When Ford had broached the subject
with his staff only a week or so before, he had described his
rationale: " The degrading spectacle of a former President
in a prisoners dock; the near impossibility of finding
an open-minded jury anywhere in the country; the press stories
about every step in the process that would revive the whole
rotten mess of Watergate." Even if Nixon was tried,
in the end, he might be found innocent; or even if not, perhaps
a future president would pardon him after all the tumult.26 Ford
defended his pardon decision vigorously, especially accusations
that he had made a "deal" for the presidency, even appearing
before a congressional committee to explain it. Yet his action
caused a decline in his initial popularity from which he never
fully recovered. Ford made a bid for the presidency in his own
right in 1976, but was defeated in a close election with Jimmy
Carter. In the wake of the Watergate scandal, Carter presented
himself as an outsider "who had not been involved in any
way with Washington." The republic dusted itself off, and
took a new direction.
|