Mary Arthur was born in New York on July 5, 1841. Mary was the sister of future President Chester A. Arthur, nearly twelve years her senior, and the youngest child of William and Malvina Arthur. As a young woman, she married John E. McElroy, with whom she had four children; the family settled in Albany, New York.
Mary Arthur McElroy’s brother, Chester A. Arthur, was a widower when he assumed the presidency in 1881; his wife, Ellen “Nell” Lewis Herndon Arthur, had passed away from pneumonia in 1880. Mrs. McElroy agreed to act as White House hostess during the busy winter social season, returning to Albany in the spring to be with her husband and children. While in Washington, D.C., Mrs. McElroy performed the duties of first lady, hosting well-attended receptions, balls, and dinners while living at the Executive Mansion. Newspapers called her “a general favorite” at the White House.
Mrs. McElroy served as part-time White House hostess until the end of her brother’s administration in 1885. When Chester A. Arthur passed away in 1886, the McElroys became the legal guardians of his daughter, Nell. In the final years of her life, Mary Arthur McElroy expressed her devotion to civil rights while simultaneously opposing women’s suffrage. She passed away on January 8, 1917.
You Might Also Like
The 2021 First Ladies Symposium
Mid-Century Fashion and the First Ladies: From Ready-to-Wear to Haute Couture
Foreword, William SealeThe Style of First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt: Fashion and Frugality in Times of Depression and War, Morgan BlattenbergThe...
The First Ladies
Read Digital Edition Foreword, William SealeThe Office of the First Lady: Managing Public Duties, Private Lives, and Changing Expectations, Anita...
First Ladies' Private Lives
In the early decades of the republic a president's wife, like other wives, seldom displayed her private life to the...
Podcast Conversations from History Happy Hour
In this first episode of 2021, White House Historical Association President Stewart D. McLaurin introduces the Association’s popular virtual program Hi...
Collection Animal Ambassadors
Animals, whether pampered household pets, working livestock, birds, squirrels, or strays, have long been a major part of White House...
Collection The Presidents
Biographies & Portraits
Podcast Entertaining at the White House
From diplomatic dinners to holiday gatherings, the White House has always played a central role in the nation’s official en...
Collection Women and the White House
While there has yet to be a female president, women have played an integral role in shaping the White House...
Collection Cherry Blossoms
Since the first cherry blossom planting in 1912 by First Lady Helen Herron Taft, Washingtonians have celebrated the scenic beauty and...
Podcast Fearless Leadership: A Conversation with Jean Case
Fearless leaders have walked the halls of White House for centuries. In this episode, White House Historical Association President Stewart...
Collection The First Ladies
Biographies & Portraits